Alice Miller, child abuse and mistreatment

APRIL 2010

MARCH 2010

FEBRUARY 2010

JANUARY 2010

DECEMBER 2009

NOVEMBER 2009

OCTOBER 2009

SEPTEMBER 2009

AUGUST 2009

JULY 2009

JUNE 2009

MAY 2009

APRIL 2009

MARCH 2009

FEBRUARY 2009

JANUARY 2009

DECEMBER 2008

NOVEMBER 2008

OCTOBER 2008

SEPTEMBER 2008

AUGUST 2008

JULY 2008

JUNE 2008

MAY 2008

APRIL 2008

MARCH 2008

FEBRUARY 2008

JANUARY 2008

DECEMBER 2007

NOVEMBER 2007

OCTOBER 2007

SEPTEMBER 2007

AUGUST 2007

JULY 2007

JUNE 2007

MAY 2007

APRIL 2007

MARCH 2007

FEBRUARY 2007

JANUARY 2007

DECEMBER 2006

NOVEMBER 2006

OCTOBER 2006

SEPTEMBER 2006

AUGUST 2006

JULY 2006

JUNE 2006

MAY 2006

APRIL 2006

MARCH 2006

FEBRUARY 2006

JANUARY 2006

DECEMBER 2005

NOVEMBER 2005

OCTOBER 2005

SEPTEMBER 2005

AUGUST 2005

JULY 2005

Psychiatry and abuse
Wednesday August 22, 2007

Dear Ms. Miller,

I read S.T's mail "Diagnonsense", and also the mentioned January mail, and I want to add a testimony of my own. In the last year of medical school, I was appointed personal "therapist" of a 32-year old female "schizophrenic". After I talked to the "patient" several times, I could not find any sign of "mental illness" in her. She talked to me about being sexually harassed by one of the staff, and this was interpreted (after a formal, non revealing "investigation") as a sign of "deterioration" in my patient's "condition". This was not the first time she was talking about sexual abuse.

My patient was first hospitalized when she was sixteen. She was reportedly very upset then and talked loudly about being sexually exploited by her father and uncle. Massive doses of medication and intensive "medical" brainwash made her take back what she said and denounce the truth. Since then she was hospitalized several times, every time with a new "paranoia" about sexual harassment.

When I met her she was at first hesitant to talk about the abuse, and claiming she was in agreement with her psychiatrists. She said she understands that she was crazy, and that in reality, what she thought that happen didn't really happen. When I asked her how she got to that conclusion, she said that's what the doctors all say. I did not argue with her and instead asked her questions about what she remembered. I listened to her I thought she looked reliable. It didn't look like she was making it up, or trying to make the story look big. On the contrary, it looked like she was minimizing terrible abuse. I asked her if she really intentionally made this all up, and she said no. But because the doctors say she was "insane" at the time, then she must have imagined it.

This was her only problem: she was completely invalidated and isolated by the label of "paranoid schizophrenia", and so she couldn't trust herself at all . When I looked in her earliest hospital files, I discovered that the psychologist in charge of the "case" determined, after a brief, non revealing "investigation", that the abuse probably never happened, and the girl is suffering from delusions. No evidence was given. The nature and extent of "investigation" were not recorded. No one dared to question the original diagnosis in all her subsequent hospitalizations. It seems that no one had taken the girl's complaints seriously. And worse - because from the day she was "diagnosed", no one believed anything she said anymore, and so could be easily controlled and further abused in the future.

But now she could feel I believe her, and in a very short time she was very confident in her truth and didn't look confused at all. But she still found it hard to give up the idea that "something was the matter with her". It took me several more months to convince her that she was never schizophrenic and that she did not need drugs. Her self-esteem was completely ruined by this "diagnosis" - years of humiliation cannot be easily erased.

I don't think this case is unique. Every day, people who tell intolerable truths are labeled as "paranoid schizophrenics" by psychiatrists. This case only shows how easy it is to invalidate a victim like that. The label of "mental illness" often is nothing but the invalidation, stigmatization, humiliation, and drugging of victims who try to complain. The complaint isn't never seriously investigated (as in criminal investigations), and the case is closed forever. Psychiatry is thus a crucial factor in eliminating victims' voices, abusing them "for their own good", and "protecting" society from the outcry of the abused.

N., Israel.

AM: Thank you for your letter. Your case is very interesting. You see how the patient could regain her trust in her own memory when you didn't refuse to believe her like the other doctor did. But I think that believing in a neutral position is not enough. The patients needed more, she needed your INDIGNATION about the deeds of her perpetrators. Most doctors don't dare to feel and to show this feeling because they have pity with their own parents and are afraid to lose their love if they are appalled about parents’ cruelty. Can you remember how you reacted to the story of abuse in this case?

Top